9BabyNames Baby names with meanings & US popularity data Italiano

Karlie vs Amelia

How Karlie and Amelia compare across 146 years of US Social Security Administration baby-name records — popularity history, peak years, current rank, and which name overtook which.

Open Name Tournament

Karlie

Female · German

Meaning: Womanly: Strength. Feminine Of Karl.

Amelia

Female · German

Meaning: Defender ANSELMA

US Popularity History — Side-by-Side

Annual US births named Karlie (girls) vs Amelia (girls), from US Social Security Administration national records.

Source: US Social Security Administration. Names appearing fewer than 5 times per year are suppressed by SSA.

Quick Stats

Metric Karlie Amelia
Peak year (most US births) 2004 — 445 girls 2021 — 13,032 girls
Peak rank #617 #4
Most recent rank (2017) #960 (276 births) #4 (12,699 births)
Total US births since 1880 6,103 204,529
Last 10 years (2008–2017) 3,057 124,049

Peak comparison takeaway

At its all-time peak, Amelia reached 13,032 US births in 2021 — 12,587 more than Karlie's peak count.

Strongest States — Last 10 Years

States where each name ranked highest, from SSA's state-level dataset. Lower average rank = name appears closer to the top of that state's girls-name list.

Karlie — top 5 states

#StateAvg rankBirths
1 Mississippi #327 61
2 Louisiana #451 91
3 Arkansas #521 32
4 Missouri #559 45
5 Alabama #568 76

Amelia — top 5 states

#StateAvg rankBirths
1 Louisiana #3 1,899
2 Alaska #3 333
3 Indiana #3 2,887
4 West Virginia #3 747
5 Kentucky #3 1,855

Want a different comparison?

Data & methodology

Source: US Social Security Administration national baby names dataset 1880–2025 (CC0 public domain). Names with fewer than 5 occurrences in a given year are suppressed by SSA. State-level coverage runs 1910–2025. Crossover detection compares annual birth counts (not ranks) for each year both names appear. Methodology: see full notes. More comparisons →